R.L. Stine’s beloved books have been giving fans Goosebumps for decades. Now, Disney+ continues the tradition with a new season of the anthology series adaptation, titled Goosebumps: The Vanishing.

Season 2 returns in January. But before the new episodes drop, we had the chance to speak to some of the stars. When chatting with Ana Ortiz and Francesca Noel, we learned more about how the upcoming episodes filmed in a variety of creepy places around New York City. Check out our interview below to learn which of these locations really gave them goosebumps.

About Goosebumps: The Vanishing

In Goosebumps: The Vanishing, twins Cece and Devin Brewer are sent to spend a summer with their divorced dad. But a threat is stirring in Gravesend, Brooklyn. They quickly realize that dark secrets are among them, triggering a chain of events that unravel a profound mystery. As they delve into the unknown, Cece, Devin and their friends — Alex, CJ, and Frankie — find themselves entangled in the chilling tale of four teenagers who mysteriously vanished in 1994.

Emmy Award nominee David Schwimmer leads a brand-new cast as Anthony Brewer, a former botany professor who has immersed himself in science and mystery. The season also stars Ana Ortiz as police detective Jen; Jayden Bartels as Cece and Sam McCarthy as Devin; Elijah M. Cooper as CJ, Galilea La Salvia as Frankie, Francesca Noel as Alex, and Stony Blyden as Trey.

Goosebumps: The Vanishing premieres on Disney+ and Hulu January 10.